|
|
Barack Obama  Joined: 9/20/2005 Posts: 16,516  
|
I think the idea is sound but the application thus far has been a bit shit.
In the Pies game, there was a toe-poke goal which the umpire referred, as he wasn't sure if it hit the post. There was at least one clear angle that showed it didn't yet the third umpire, who I'm assuming is a borderline retard, said it was inconclusive.
And why does he need to put on a stupid voice when reporting back the decision. "The decision is complete". Like really?
|
|
|
Alex Murphy  Joined: 11/4/2006 Posts: 4,201 Location: Dubbo NSW
|
It seems to be working ok in what I've seen ... needs more camera angles rather than just two tho' ... the voice sounded a bit like AFL's Adrian Anderson? ^^^^^^^**************************^^^^^^^
Kochie, KT, Ken, KO ... getting it right! #weareportadelaide
|
|
|
Barack Obama Joined: 9/20/2005 Posts: 16,516
|
The goal by Blair at the end, why was that even referred? I think that umpires who make stupid referrals should be retrospectively sacked. That was shocking.
It's not only a stupid voice but it's incredibly slow. It's like he's demented.
|
|
|
Zinedine Zidane  Joined: 11/3/2009 Posts: 3,438 Location: always coasting..
|
Cold Dog wrote:The goal by Blair at the end, why was that even referred? I think that umpires who make stupid referrals should be retrospectively sacked. That was shocking.
It's not only a stupid voice but it's incredibly slow. It's like he's demented. aren't all umpires demented?  ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Hot Pies and Mustard
|
|
|
Arnold Palmer Joined: 12/14/2006 Posts: 14,306 Location: perth
|
Cold Dog wrote:The goal by Blair at the end, why was that even referred? I think that umpires who make stupid referrals should be retrospectively sacked. That was shocking.
It's not only a stupid voice but it's incredibly slow. It's like he's demented. thought it might of touched it with his hand the different angles make it even worse blair was a goal any day but angles made it close i think the goalies just use it as back up now  dont hate the player hate the game
|
|
|
Barack Obama Joined: 9/20/2005 Posts: 16,516
|
jujuno wrote:Cold Dog wrote:The goal by Blair at the end, why was that even referred? I think that umpires who make stupid referrals should be retrospectively sacked. That was shocking.
It's not only a stupid voice but it's incredibly slow. It's like he's demented. aren't all umpires demented? You make a fair point juju. 
|
|
|
Alex Murphy Joined: 11/4/2006 Posts: 4,201 Location: Dubbo NSW
|
Last weekend in Coll v Geelong there was review called for a behind - different calls of goal/boundary umps... Ball kicked wild and at least double post height...boundary ump under post says out- goal umpire running across to post says behind. The field ump lost contact with 'review guys' ... says its taking too long we'll go with a behind? what? Boundary guy's call should have been taken-he was parked under ball and looking up! Review should only be used for goal line or touch/not touch posts until we have numerous cameras and/or 'tennis hawk-eye like' technology ^^^^^^^**************************^^^^^^^
Kochie, KT, Ken, KO ... getting it right! #weareportadelaide
|
|
|
Alex Murphy Joined: 11/4/2006 Posts: 4,201 Location: Dubbo NSW
|
Why isnt there a goal-line camera? How hard can that be? This was brought in on the run?  ^^^^^^^**************************^^^^^^^
Kochie, KT, Ken, KO ... getting it right! #weareportadelaide
|
|
|
Brian Lara  Joined: 9/24/2005 Posts: 3,368 Location: Australia
|
I havent seen a lot of games the past week and a half, but I haven't noticed any replays in the matches that I have managed to watch. Now that the novelty has worn off a bit, theyre not pushing for replays as often?
|
|
|
Ian Thorpe  Joined: 1/18/2007 Posts: 5,789
|
RudeNuT wrote:I havent seen a lot of games the past week and a half, but I haven't noticed any replays in the matches that I have managed to watch.
Now that the novelty has worn off a bit, theyre not pushing for replays as often? Hasnt been used a lot lately. Havent seen it but apparently there was a contentious non goal given to Darling from West Coast late in the game. Just heresay. Probabaly didnt deserve to win that game anyways
|
|
|
Alex Murphy Joined: 11/4/2006 Posts: 4,201 Location: Dubbo NSW
|
I reckon the umps have made a concious effort to back in the goal ump's eye in the past few weeks ... def less in games I have seen. Def a good thing otheriwse it will be like cricket where a run-out thats metres short gets referred coz the umps are too lazy! ^^^^^^^**************************^^^^^^^
Kochie, KT, Ken, KO ... getting it right! #weareportadelaide
|
|
|
Arnold Palmer Joined: 12/14/2006 Posts: 14,306 Location: perth
|
Sebastian wrote:RudeNuT wrote:I havent seen a lot of games the past week and a half, but I haven't noticed any replays in the matches that I have managed to watch.
Now that the novelty has worn off a bit, theyre not pushing for replays as often? Hasnt been used a lot lately. Havent seen it but apparently there was a contentious non goal given to Darling from West Coast late in the game. Just heresay. Probabaly didnt deserve to win that game anyways no that was darling trying to be a hero if he sheppards the lions player the ball roles through for a goal instead he tried to soccer is and the lions player got a touch on not that is one eye eagles supporters trying to find an excuse not having a crack at you but its all ive been hearing and its bs darlings reaction showed what he did fuck i hate eagles supporters in general that is dont hate the player hate the game
|
|
|
Alex Murphy Joined: 11/4/2006 Posts: 4,201 Location: Dubbo NSW
|
nivek48 wrote:I reckon the umps have made a concious effort to back in the goal ump's eye in the past few weeks ... def less in games I have seen. Def a good thing otheriwse it will be like cricket where a run-out thats metres short gets referred coz the umps are too lazy! This weekend was farcical ... A richmond clear goal, goal ump says point ... no call for review...wasnt one of 3 field umps watching? A number of reviews in Port v Adelaide that was incoonclusive and just waited forever for review decision. I think one a goal was called - ball back at centre and still waiting for review finish!!!??? WTF? Seems after a few weeks of quiet and being used ok ... its now - let's do all or nothing in a game? Get rid of it til they work out cameras etc ^^^^^^^**************************^^^^^^^
Kochie, KT, Ken, KO ... getting it right! #weareportadelaide
|
|
|
|
Guest
|